When Parents Push Back: Navigating Casting Complaints with Confidence
Plus, your weekly round-up of theatre news you may have missed!
Welcome to The Scene, your weekly round-up of theatre news you may have missed. In this week's edition:
We explore ways to navigate parental pushback on casting with empathy and confidence, while reinforcing a positive and professional culture in your theatre program.
Don’t miss this week’s free read from Playscripts: The Holiday Channel Christmas Movie Wonderthon by Don Zolidis.
Don’t miss the latest episode of The Scene podcast, featuring a conversation with Tony Award-winning playwright of Eureka Day, Jonathan Spector.
So, raise the curtain and shine the spotlight as we dive into another thrilling week in the theatre world. Welcome to The Scene.
Taraji P. Henson and Cedric 'The Entertainer' to Star in Joe Turner's Come and Gone Broadway Revival by Andrew Gans, Margaret Hall, Playbill | Debbie Allen will direct the August Wilson classic next year. Read...
The ‘Heathers’ Musical Is Back, With a Little Less Darkness by Elisabeth Vincentelli, The New York Times | An adaptation of the 1980s teen movie with an apocalyptic bent was fine-tuned in London. Now it’s returning to New York. Read...
Samuel D. Hunter's Little Bear Ridge Road Sets Broadway Bow; Scott Rudin Will Produce by Logan Culwell-Block, Playbill | Laurie Metcalf and Micah Stock are starring after premiering the work at Chicago's Steppenwolf Theatre last year. Read...
Richard Greenberg, Playwright Whose ‘Take Me Out’ Won a Tony, Dies at 67 by Clay Risen, The New York Times | More than 30 of his plays were produced on Broadway and off. Many of them dealt with the manners and mores of New York’s upper middle class. Read...
24 Theater Books for Your Summer 2025 Reading List by Nicole Rosky, Broadway World | Broadway authors this season include David Mamet, Debbie Gibson, and more. Read...
Mark Brokaw, Theater Director Who Gave Rising Talent a Stage, Dies at 66 by Joanne Kaufman, The New York Times | On and off Broadway, he worked with playwrights like Kenneth Lonergan and Paula Vogel, combining complex storytelling with the simplest possible productions. Read...
The Big Idea
When Parents Push Back: Navigating Casting Complaints with Confidence
by Zach Dulli, The Scene
Few things test a director’s patience like a disgruntled parent who insists their child was “robbed” of a role. It’s an emotional situation, especially when you know how much time, effort, and care you’ve put into casting. While it’s natural to feel defensive, how you handle these interactions can make or break your relationship with families and set the tone for how your program is viewed. A respectful, professional approach can defuse tension, build trust, and ensure your casting process remains fair.
Strategies for Handling Complaints
Transparency from the Start - The best way to avoid pushback is to head it off before it begins. Before auditions, clearly explain your casting process to students and their families. Hold a pre-audition meeting to outline your expectations, criteria, and any rubrics or scoring systems you’ll use. Walk them through how you assess acting, singing, and dancing (if applicable), and clarify how casting decisions are made to serve the production. Be upfront about any program philosophies, such as whether seniority plays a role in casting or if roles are based solely on performance during auditions. When people understand the process and see it’s transparent, they’re far less likely to perceive favoritism or question your decisions.
Focus on Growth - When a parent does approach you with concerns, shift the conversation to focus on their child’s development rather than the role they were cast in. Begin by acknowledging their feelings: “I know auditions can be a stressful process, and I appreciate how much your child cares about being involved.” Then, redirect to highlight the positives. For example:
“I see so much potential in your child, and I think this role will really help them grow as a performer.”
“This character has some wonderful comedic moments that will let them showcase their timing.”
“This role has some really complex emotions that I think will challenge your child to take their acting skills to the next level.”
By framing the discussion around growth opportunities, you help parents see the value of their child’s contribution, even if it wasn’t the lead role.
Listen, but Stand Your Ground - While it’s important to approach these conversations with empathy, it’s equally important to stay firm in your decisions. Explain that casting isn’t just about rewarding individual talent; it’s about assembling a cast that works together to tell the story. Reiterate that your goal is to create the best possible production while also giving all students opportunities to grow. For example, you might say:
“Casting is one of the hardest parts of my job because I care deeply about each student, but ultimately, my responsibility is to cast the show in a way that serves the story we’re telling. Every role is important, and I believe your child is in a position where they can contribute meaningfully and have a great experience.”
Avoid apologizing for your decisions, as that can suggest doubt or weakness. Instead, remain confident and professional while showing that you understand their concerns.
Keep the Focus on the Student, Not the Parent - Sometimes, parents project their own desires onto their children, which can escalate emotions. Gently redirect the focus back to the student. For example:
“I understand your perspective, but from working with your child, I’ve seen them shine in roles like this. I’m excited to see what they’ll bring to this character.”
“Your child seems passionate about theatre, and I think this role will allow them to stretch their skills in a new direction.”
By centering the conversation on the student’s growth and experience, you can avoid getting sidetracked by a parent’s emotions or expectations.
Be Proactive in Addressing Disappointment - Anticipate that casting disappointment is inevitable and find ways to help students (and parents) process it constructively. After announcing the cast list, hold an optional group discussion or one-on-one conversations with students who have concerns. Explain your decision-making process, highlight their strengths, and offer guidance on how they can continue to improve for future productions. Additionally, if you notice a parent who seems upset, reach out to them first. A quick email or phone call acknowledging their child’s enthusiasm for the program and expressing excitement about their role can go a long way in preventing conflicts.
Keeping the Drama On Stage
Casting is often the most emotionally charged part of the production process. How you handle it sets the tone for your entire program. Foster a culture of professionalism and respect by establishing a few ground rules:
Hold Pre-Audition Meetings - A pre-audition meeting is one of the most effective tools for setting the tone of your casting process and ensuring that students (and their parents) understand what to expect. It’s your chance to establish transparency, clarify expectations, and reduce misunderstandings before they arise. Use this time to explain your casting philosophy, expectations, and how you’ll evaluate auditions.
Post Results Thoughtfully - The timing and method of announcing your cast list can significantly affect how students process the news. Avoid posting the cast list first thing in the morning, which can lead to distractions and emotional reactions during the school day. Instead, consider announcing the cast on a Friday afternoon. This gives students the weekend to process the decisions privately, away from the immediate pressures of school. Share the list in a way that minimizes comparison, such as through individual emails or sealed envelopes, or if you post it publicly, include a statement highlighting the value of every role in the production. By being intentional about how and when you announce the cast, you create a more supportive environment that prioritizes student well-being and program unity.
Celebrate Every Role - One of the most important messages you can reinforce in your program is that every role in a production is equally important. Students often equate their value with the size of their role, which can lead to disappointment or disengagement. As the director, it’s your job to shift that perspective and celebrate the significance of every contribution, whether onstage, backstage, or in the pit.
Final Bow
Casting is more than assigning roles; it’s a cornerstone of your program’s culture and an opportunity to help students grow as performers, collaborators, and individuals. While the process comes with challenges, it’s also a chance to teach lessons that will stick with your students far beyond the stage.
As a director, you’re not just creating a show, you’re creating an environment where students feel seen, valued, and capable of more than they thought possible. It’s not about producing perfection; it’s about fostering growth, encouraging risk-taking, and instilling a sense of pride in every participant. When you approach casting with transparency, fairness, and a genuine desire to bring out the best in your students, you lay the foundation for a program where they’ll feel supported, inspired, and excited to return year after year.
So, as you navigate the difficult decisions and the inevitable curveballs of casting, remember that your work goes far beyond the applause on opening night. Your true impact lies in the relationships you build, the lessons you share, and the community you foster. Take a deep breath, trust your instincts, and embrace the messy, magical process of putting your show together. After all, the curtain call isn’t just for the students, it’s for you, too. Break a leg!
Burlesque the Musical Arrives in London's West End by Andrew Gans, Margaret Hall, Playbill | Steve Antin's new musical, based on the 2010 film of the same name, features songs by Christina Aguilera and Sia. Read...
Paranormal Activity Stage Show Sets West End Debut by Rebecca Rubin, Variety | A new play inspired by the hit horror film franchise will open on the West End this winter. Read...
Tony Award winner Robert Sean Leonard and Paten Hughes to star in world premiere play Interview by Tanyel Gumushan, WhatsOnStage | Interview will run for a limited engagement in London. Read...
John Tartaglia Steps Into The Muny’s Frozen, Replacing Injured Actor by Andrew Gans, Playbill | The Avenue Q star is also directing the musical at the St. Louis venue. Read...
Hamlet and Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead to Play in Rep at PA Shakespeare Festival by Linda Buchwald, Theatre Mania | Both shows are led by Biko Eisen-Martin, Sean Close, and Maboud Ebrahimzadeh. Read...
Marissa Jaret Winokur to Direct Hairspray in California by Margaret Hall, Playbill | Winokur won a Tony Award for her performance as Tracy Turnblad in the original Broadway production. Read...
Free Reads of the Week
Read entire plays for free! Playscripts offers a selection of full-length and one-act plays that you can access for free, which is ideal for use in theatre productions, school performances, or competitions. To explore these titles, click on the cover image below or select the "READ FOR FREE" button at the bottom of this section. This action will direct you to the play's page on the Playscripts website. Once there, click "READ NOW" to begin enjoying the play immediately!
The Holiday Channel Christmas Movie Wonderthon by Don Zolidis
The Story: Christmas: a time for magic. A time for the traditions we cherish. A time to watch as many original TV movies as a human being can possibly endure. But now with The Holiday Channel Christmas Movie Wonderthon, you can enjoy the sugar rush of six Christmas movies all at once! Welcome to Hopewood Falls, Vermont, where singles in adorable sweaters converge to look for love. Can disguises help royalty and/or movie stars find the down-to-earth connections they crave? Will evil city slickers destroy charming inns and/or Christmas tree farms? Isn't it a little creepy for a meet-cute to depend on one person being in a coma? Grab a hot chocolate and your favorite wise single friend to find out in this wildly entertaining parody of holiday rom-coms.
Genre: Comedy | Run-Time: 90-100 minutes | Casting: 7 W, 7 M, 2 Any (16-31 actors possible: 7-15 W, 7-16 M) | Set: An inn lobby.
Please note: From May 15 to August 15, The Scene will be moving to a bi-weekly publishing schedule. We'll return to our regular weekly schedule after that. Thanks for your continued support, and have a great summer!
Especially true in middle school casting. I always emphasized to parents that MS productions were about process and not product, and that every student no matter what the role benefitted from that process.